Whale’s Rib Tavern

At this time, the Whale’s Rib Tavern will only be open to the public for special events.  Exclusively for our Inn guests, we will continue to include a full, delicious breakfast as part of the room rate. We have a wine/beer/cocktail list available for guests.  We also have specials several nights during the week.

Lobster Dinner at Pilgrim's Inn RestaurantMondays: Lobster Night

On Mondays from 5-6:30 PM, we will offer a lobster dinner, by advanced reservation (inn guests only).

Sundays & Tuesdays – Thursdays: Small Plate Menu

As an option on SundayTuesdayWednesday, and Thursday evenings from 5:30-7pm, upon request, we will be offering an a la carte small plate menu for hungry Pilgrim’s Inn guests. Be sure to check in with us at breakfast or prior to arrival if you might want to dine in that night.

The small plate menu may change with the season, but we will be offering items such as:
Local Cheese & Charcuterie Plate
Flatbread Pizza
Soup and/or Salad
Grilled Cheese Toasts featuring local chutney or topping of the day
Ice Cream

Depending on how many people are dining in on a given evening, you may have the cozy bar booth all to yourself!  At this time, we are unable to accommodate guests of Pilgrim’s Inn guests for dinner.

Weekends: Local Restaurants

On Fridays and Saturdays, we are happy to refer you to one of the local restaurants.

Dinner Events:

We have special events scheduled for the following dates, we are unable to offer the small plate menu or lobster dinners on these dates:


October 6th – View Menu & Event Details

Call to make reservations today!




Learn More About Our Breakfast